Respecting Those Killed, Demanding Changes in Reporting: Protest at Broadcasting House 19/11/12 12-3pm

Israel – Gaza conflict: there will be a protest from 12-3 outside the BBC building Broadcasting House, Portland Place, London from 12-3pm Monday 19 November.

First of all, to clarify, this site and its supporters are not pro or anti Palestinian or Israeli. We are pro all life, pro peace, pro truth. Above all in this context we are pro good journalism.

At the protest on Monday we will be both paying respects to the dead on both sides, and petitioning the BBC to drastically change its reporting of the hostilities in specific ways:

In BBC news reports on TV, Radio and Online:

1) Higher numbers of Palestinian deaths are consistently presented as secondary to smaller numbers of Israeli deaths.

WE DEMAND A FAIR BBC THAT REPORTS DEATHS ON BOTH SIDES WITH EQUAL WEIGHT.

2) Consistently, Israeli viewpoints, whether in the form of well-trained Israeli spokespeople or our own political leaders, are given predominance, with a tiny proportion of time for Palestinian viewpoints:

WE DEMAND A FAIR BBC THAT GIVES EQUAL AMOUNTS OF AIRTIME TO VIEWPOINTS AND SUPPORTERS OF EACH SIDE.

3) Israeli attacks are consistently justified by being cosseted in phrases like ‘in response to…’ and ‘in retaliation for…’

WE DEMAND A FAIR BBC THAT IS NOT ONE-SIDED IN LAYING BLAME, AND FOCUSES PRIMARILY ON FACTS.

4) The arbitrary start-date of this conflict and timeline of events have been chosen to falsely point the finger at Palestinians as ‘aggressors’.

WE DEMAND A FAIR BBC THAT PROVIDES ACCURATE DETAILS AND TIMELINE OF ISRAELI AND PALESTINIAN ATTACKS.

5) The history of illegal Israeli occupation, and its daily spread, the blocking of Palestinian attempts at statehood, the democratic mandate of Hamas and the obscene inhumanity of the siege of Gaza is consistently overlooked in reports and so regarded as acceptable.

WE DEMAND A FAIR BBC THAT GIVES THE BACKGROUND AND DAILY REALITY OF THIS CONFLICT.

So far in this conflict, as has been seen for many years again and again on the BBC, it has blatantly valued Israeli lives over Palestinian and aired almost exclusively pro Israeli viewpoints.

As an example of the kind of biased reporting that has caused such offence: I literally had to stop my car during a BBC Radio 5 Live news report on Thursday to calm myself down and note down what was said as it was so revoltingly one-sided. I found it online and for a few more days you can hear it here if you want: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01nt2q7

In summary: “3 israelis were killed by rockets from Gaza” – this is the headline, followed by a surprisingly long and very emotive recording (isn’t this still the headlines?) of an Israeli father talking about his concerns for his children and wife hiding in their house together, followed by a much briefer mention that 3 Palestinians were also killed. Later, which you wouldn’t even catch if you only wanted the headlines, we hear, after the foreign secretary’s explanation that the Palestinians are to blame, that not 3 but ELEVEN Palestinians were killed. This, we are told, all followed Israel’s assassination of a key Palestinian figure in retaliation to Palestinian rocket attacks. Finally, as a gesture to balanced reporting we hear a UN official calling for no escalation on either side.

It’s all there really, well a lot of it: the blatant racist prioritising of Israeli deaths over Palestinian; the emotive use of an Israeli witness, but no Palestinian; the use of an ‘expert voice’ – ok, William Hague – explaining that it’s the Palestinians’ fault, but no expert with a pro Palestinian view; the parroting of the Israeli government’s arbitrary selection of a timeline of events that allows pointing the finger of blame at Palestinians and casting Israel as the victim purely defending itself; and I imagine some timeline type issue would be the reason given for the 3 Palestinian deaths at the end of the headline morphing into 11 a minute later.

I would strongly recommend these 2 reports on BBC bias on this conflict:

one by the editors of Media Lens (www.medialens.org): http://ow.ly/flNdu ;

the other by the editors of News Unspun (www.newsunspun.org) http://www.newsunspun.org/article/whitewashing-an-assault-bbc-coverage-of-the-israelgaza-ceasefire

And this report by FAIR (www.fair.org) on the timeline of events leading to current hostilities. http://www.fair.org/blog/2012/11/15/when-does-israelpalestine-violence-start

11 thoughts on “Respecting Those Killed, Demanding Changes in Reporting: Protest at Broadcasting House 19/11/12 12-3pm

  1. Ama Menec

    I’ve been appalled by the bias in favour of Israel displayed by the BBC, particularly Radio 4 which I listen to most of the day whilst working. We all expect better of the BBC than this, and it makes the UK look bad to the rest of the world when the reporting is so unbalanced.

    Reply
  2. robbie hardy

    Thankyou! I cannot believe how blatant this bias has become. This mornings report on BBC news was so thick with pro Israeli propoganda it felt truly criminal.
    Best wishes and thanks this.

    Reply
  3. fixerken

    It’s enough having to hear our BIASED government speak on this subject. I do not want to be hearing the same BIAS from the BBC that I am compelled to pay a licence fee to.

    Reply
  4. Pingback: BBC demonstration: Bias in Israel-Gaza Reporting | Shahrar for London

  5. Zeljka

    Things were never really differnt here. It seems like UK goverment (not just the present one) & BBC are kept by Israel. Sad state of affairs.

    Reply
    1. wethelicencepayers Post author

      Hi Zeljka

      Thanks for your post.

      Perhaps some influence can be brought to bear given that the BBC, we keep hearing, is the best broadcaster in the world, its journalists the most objective, seeking out truth, not just taking someone’s word for something; given that they want to maintain that image, it is up to people who disagree to show it to be false. I’m going to post something on the website about what combined efforts might achieve.

      All the best

      Mark

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s